A constant challenge (folly) investors face is that of predicting the following year’s returns. Too often, investors obsess with trying to predict next year’s winner – even as the evidence shows that making short term predictions is virtually impossible.
This graphic shows the calendar year returns of different asset classes. It highlights the challenge of trying to predict the asset class that will perform well in the coming 12 months.
Although interesting, a chart like this doesn’t necessarily help bring you a solution. That’s why the traditional advice for short term investment goals is to invest in cash. While cash may not produce the highest return (it’s the only asset class never to rank 1st over this period), it does produce returns with the highest level of certainty.
We believe the best way to harness asset class returns and to ensure you hold next year’s winner is to diversify. To quote an interview with Charles Ellis, “Diversification says, I don’t know everything.” Given that we can’t know everything, we believe you should diversify your clients’ portfolios. But diversifying to reach client goals doesn’t mean naively combining asset classes. As we’re about to show, as unpredictable as near-term asset class returns are, they start to become more predictable in the long term. To illustrate this, we split all asset classes into two broad categories and repeated the above exercise over different time horizons:
1. Growth Assets (Local and Global Equity and Property) and
a. Long term capital growth and inflation protection
2. Defensive Assets (Local and Global Cash and Bonds)
a. Short/medium term capital protection and income generation.
Notice in the below charts that the unpredictable pattern over one year starts to become more predictable in the medium to long term, as the fundamentals of asset class characteristics come to the fore.
1. Source: Morningstar. All returns are calendar year returns in ZAR based on rolling 1,5 and 10 years. SA Property = FTSE/JSE SAPY TR Index, SA Equity = FTSE/JSE All Share TR Index, SA Bonds = FTSE/JSE ALBI TR Index, SA cash = STFI Comp TR Index, Global Property = S&P Global Property 40 GR Index, Global Equity = MSCI World GR Index, Global Bonds = FTSE G7 GR Index . Past performance is not indicative of future performance.
When we combine assets in our multi-asset funds, we do so strategically. We use the evidence of asset class returns and align with long term client goals, instead of tactically trying to exploit near term predictions. It is amazing to see how the noise and challenges of short-term predictions tends to fade when we focus on the client’s goals. By minimizing the moving parts and focusing on client objectives, we can more reliably achieve them.
By Chris Rule
OUTvest is an authorised FSP. All our investments are exposed to risk, not guaranteed and dependent on the performance of the underlying assets. Results are provided for illustrative purposes only and are amount and time horizon dependent.